This is a blog involving criminal defense issues relating to false confessions by individuals accused of crimes. One of the primary way that the government is able to obtain a verdict of guilty against a defendant in criminal defense cases is through the use of a confession. learn about assault crimes A confession is when an accused defendant claims or admits that he committed a crime that he ultimately becomes charged with. Obviously, at a trial a confession from a defendant is very powerful evidence that the accused committed the crime that he is charged with. And generally a jury believes and trusts in evidence stating that an accused confessed to a crime. Their reasoning is who would confess to a crime that they didn’t commit. However, it has become evident that criminal defendants for a variety of reasons do occasionally give false confessions. Make sure to contact the experienced former prosecutors at the Law Offices of Kelly & Conte if you have been charged with a crime involving a false confession.
So what can be done in a Criminal Defense case involving a false confession? In the case of Commonwealth vs Alicia the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania found that the defense is not permitted to present evidence from an expert witness stating that a criminal defendant’s confession was false. eyewitness testimony The court made this ruling because they believed that the truth or falsity of a criminal defendant’s confession is left to the jury’s determination based on their life experience and assessment of the facts. SO what is a criminal defendant left to do in combating false confessions? Generally an attorney should show that the specific facts that the defendant agreed to were facts given to the defendant by the police. Specifically, the defendant only knew the specifics of the crime, the clothing of the victim, the layout of the house etc because those facts were provided by the police during the interrogation.